anvilfire logo (c) 1998 by Patrick Dempsey
anvilfire home

Blacksmithing News and Events
Coat of Arms from the town of  Eskilstuna, Sweden
Eskilstuna
Volume 24 - Page 16 of 16 June 2, 2001 - Addendum
ABANA Anvil Firing Controversy
June 2 letter from new SERBC president Barry Myers to ABANA president Doug Learn

Mr. Kagele, please forward this letter to Doug Learn as I cannot find his address and wish him to know of our feelings regarding the recent dismissal of our Chapter and the other Chapters of the Southeastern Region.

Dear Sir:

As incoming president of the Southeastern Region Blacksmiths Conference, Inc. (SERBC) and vice-president of the Philip Simmons Artist Blacksmith Guild of South Carolina, it is incumbent on me to make a statement about the expulsion of the seven former Chapters of ABANA that host the SERBC.

We are not angry with ABANA. We are angry with President Doug Learn and the ABANA Board because they would not work with the Southeastern chapters concerning this problem. We want President Learn and the ABANA Board to realize that we are not easily cowed by a groundless edict.  We resent being dismissed by President Learn.

We in the Philip Simmons Guild further resent that we haven't been formerly notified by ABANA in a letter to our President, Robert Hill, III.  Do not look for reapplication to ABANA because we did not withdraw in the first place. If ABANA changes it's mind, asks us to come back into ABANA (after doing away with their petty anvil shoot policy), I will try to lead my organization in that direction, as I think all of the SERBC board members will.

At the Conference, we were informed by an ABANA Board member that the policy has never been voted on by the ABANA Board.  Had the policy been approved by the Board, it may not have prevented the anvil shooting, but it would have had the weight of the Board.  It would have still been a silly, petty, uninformed edict, but it would have had the weight of the Board.

From the recent publication of the 1997 Anvil Shooting Policy (that I have seen since the Conference), I take the following:

"No Anvil Shoot or like form of public entertainment by propelling anvils into the air will be scheduled, conducted, allowed, or directly or indirectly advertised, publically [sic] announced or noted:

"1. At any ABANA sponsored public or private event;

"2. At any event sponsored by any other individuals or organizations who have used ABANA's name in their promotion of the event;

"3. At any event, Chapter function, school or demonstration sponsored by other individuals or organizations that borrow, rent, or use ABANA's Mobile Teaching Station at the event of any other ABANA equipment or property."

This Conference was not a public event, nor was it ABANA sponsored.  The Conference did not use ABANA's name in its promotion, nor did the Conference use the Mobile Teaching Station.

We had insurance.

All of the Southeastern chapters were asked months before the Conference about having an anvil shoot. At the Conference, all agreed to have a shoot except AFC who stayed neutral until their yearly meeting of their members. That didn't seem to matter to the ABANA board. One chapter is apparently no better than another to President Learn.  

The members of other expelled chapters as well as those who have not yet been expelled are brothers and sisters in blacksmithing and it will stay that way. We will keep exchanging newsletters with the other ABANA chapters if they wish to reciprocate and keep us updated on where to send them.

Our organizations will not promote ABANA as it stands now, although we still share and will promote the goals and ideals that brought us to ABANA in the first place.

Excerpt of letter from FABA

FABA gets no financial support, and little else, from ABANA. Without a doubt FABA will continue as always. FABA, like most other chapters, is a legal entity separate from ABANA. It is recognized as a nonprofit corporation in Florida and as a 501(c)(3) tax exempt educational organization by the IRS. ABANA chapters do not share ABANA's nonprofit corporate status or its exempt status under the federal tax code.

Patty Draper, President
FABA space

Excerpt of letter from OBG
Ocmulgee Blacksmith Guild will continue as it always has and that is to be one of the best blacksmith organizations in the USA. We will keep promoting blacksmithing and bladesmithing as we always have. We will not reapply as an ABANA chapter because we did not withdraw in the first place. If ABANA changes it's mind and asks us to come back into ABANA(after doing away with their petty anvil shoot policy) I will try to lead OBG in that direction as I think all of the OBG board members will. We are not angry with ABANA. We are angry with the ABANA board because they would not work with the Southeastern chapters concerning this problem. We are very disappointed that the other chapters would stand by and let a few misled board members kick out seven of their sister chapters over a tradition almost as old as blacksmithing itself. We will keep exchanging newsletters with the other ABANA chapters if they will keep us updated on where to send them.

Buster Grubbs
Ocumulgee Guild
space

CHAPTERS CRISIS FORUM
ABANA chapters policy forum (public)

ABANA By-laws
CanIron III
June 29th - July 1st North Battleford, SK
CANADA
Page 2 SERBC  Page 9  Page 10 ABANA  Page 14 CSI  Page 15 Virus  NEWS HOME
[ Anvilfire Home | Guru's Den | V. Hammer-In | Slack-Tub Pub | Power hammer Page | Links ]
[ iForge | Touchmark Registry | What's New! | Rate Card | Web Rings | 21st Century | AnvilCAM ]
May 2001 Edition
Comments to: Jock Dempsey editor@anvilfire.com
Copyright © 2001 by Jock Dempsey
Page Counter   -   Cumulitive News